Kolkata, 14-18th March 2011
Hot, hot, hot (though not hot for India, as WD reminds me). I reckon it’s at least mid-30s, though the BBC Weather Service says 32 (they must be wrong). It’s fine when we discard all our clothes and lie around under the ceiling fans, but much harder to keep up any sort of energy to go exploring and tramping round the city. We’re drinking a lot of water, but still probably not enough to keep up with the sweating. Washing dries almost instantly, even in the shade. Even reading detective novels set in the Scandinavian cold isn’t helping much...
Our arrival here wasn’t the greatest. Leaving Puri was hard, as we’d anticipated, and the early morning dash was complicated by L spreading shit of some sort (the possibilities are quite large here) over her shoes, my lap, her back pack on the way to the railway station when washing and cleaning up just wasn’t an option. WM had a bit of a sense of humour failure, not helped by the atmosphere in the AC express (chair class only) to Kolkata (lots of rich Bengali families going home after their weekend in Puri), where our fellow passengers either giggled inanely at us, or got huffy about making space to accommodate our luggage, as well as their own...
Arriving at Howrah (Hoorah!) Station, you’re on the wrong side of the Hoogly River. The Howrah Bridge was closed and the only option was to take a diversion over the other (toll) bridge further south. WD stood in a queue for over an hour for a pre-paid taxi. The idea is that you pay ahead of the journey, to remove the hassle of negotiating a fare and the inevitable arguments about using the meter, but because of the detour and the ‘terrible’ traffic (was this really any worse than normal?), the pre-paid component was only to the bridge whereupon the taxi-driver turned on his meter and we still had a big row about the correction factor at the end of the ride... Well worth the long wait in the sun, argument with an impossibly imperious and haughty lady about the evils of queue-barging (the sub-text is that it’s ok if you are sufficiently upper-class) and the guilt of under-paying the taxi-driver (we found out later that you do double what the meter says...)
![]() |
| W has adapted well to Indian norms of behaviour. |
We decided not to go to Sudder Street (where the ultra-budget accommodation and traveller scene is), but to the YWCA instead. Despite a good location, incredibly helpful staff, kittens and tennis courts, the YWCA in Kolkata did not match up to its sister in Delhi: the fabric of the building was ancient, water was only available between certain hours, rooms were tiny and dark and the whole place had the feel of a convent (WD felt quite uncomfortable at breakfast as the only man in the presence of so many very respectable ladies, and W spent a long time gazing at the huge, gory crucifixion scene that dominated our corridor). So we knew we couldn’t really stay there long, knowledge compounded by the extreme discomfort of the unleavened mattresses. Whilst the sainthood of Mother Teresa is taken as a given in these parts (she’s well on the way, having undergone beatification), there’s nothing remotely saintly about any of the rest of us...
So, it felt all right to admit to each other that we were having a bad start to being here and that sometimes, beyond culture shock, there is just, simply, cultural impasse. I hate the pushing and common disregard for others, the shouting and the casual brutality, but that’s just how it can be here and I come from somewhere else. Bad days though are transformed into better ones, by not retreating any further into irritation and frustration, but trying to re-engage in a more positive way.
The street life is much greater than elsewhere we’ve been – life is lived out, rather than indoors – with pavements heaving with outdoor-sleepers, chai stops, street children, people filling skins (yes, actual animal skins) with water from the street pump, men shaving, chatting or arguing in the shade. You feel constantly dizzy with the density and pace of the human dance around you. The poor and homeless are everywhere, begging more demanding, and a humane response to all of this poses a real and practical challenge here. A few rupees in a beggar’s bowl does little to alter anything, including your own discomfort. The children played Pig-in-the-Middle with a smiley street girl of indeterminate age, maybe M’s age, in the park and laughed and played happily with her, despite no common language, overcoming temporarily the barriers that keep people apart.
Anyway, we’ve moved to the other side of Park Street, to a Victorian Mansion block where the Sunflower Guest House occupies the 1st and 5th Floors with ‘normal’ residents on the levels in-between. It’s gloriously ramshackle, built around a huge open wooden staircase and 1940s lift-shaft. The electrical wiring and pigeon holes are from another era entirely, but the staff seem laid-back and amused by us. They initially showed us a larger than standard double room – which was fine, but we wanted a bit more space to play, school and fight, given we’re here till the weekend – so we asked if they had anything larger and they somewhat disbelievingly showed us the ‘family’ room. It’s a monster room with high 15’ ceilings, and a smaller room off it (the granny annexe?) and two shower/toilets. It has 5 (FIVE!) double-beds, intended for a vast extended Indian family, so we feel a bit inadequate and spoilt under-occupying it to such a degree. I asked for a ‘discount’ and got one (we’re visiting out of peak-season here), so it’s a bit of a bargain.
It’s equivalent to staying in the West End of London and unbelievably we’re in a bit of a food desert, stuck between the cheap but supremely greasy kathi rolls on the street, and expensive multi-cuisine restaurant-fare. We don’t have a fridge, so self-catering is extremely challenging, although we’ve given it a go for breakfasts. WD has hunted down milk, cornflakes, as well as almond croissants and coffee take-out (from Flurrys, a genteel kick-back to Raj ‘tea and cake’, despite its Deep Purple and Clapton music), proving again what a most excellent hunter-gatherer and general provider he is.
Otherwise, we have to make-do, whilst hankering for some undefined meal that we repeatedly fail to deliver. In the heat, no-one feels hungry, yet you have to remember to eat, or else things deteriorate. Tired children (nothing opens until after 7 for supper), table linen, waiters in turbans with a number-badge (forget the over-familiarity of a name), and under-dressed WPs (I’m feeling out of place with no silk sari and gold) don’t make for a good meal out. Maybe not good, but memorable though. Restaurant culture here is stuck firmly in a 70s time-warp, and we don’t think it’s intentionally ironic or post-modern as it would be at home: dim (almost to the limits of my night-vision) lighting, leatherette seats in orange, brown flock carpets, Lazy Susans – and food like macaroni cheese, sizzlers and chicken Kiev... Our favourite of these places is called Peter Cat – which we think is just the grooviest name ever. Who was Peter Cat? We need to know. The chicken Kiev deserves a special mention – less kiev, more molten garlic butter grenade, all puffed up with a little stick at the top, to detonate only under controlled conditions.
L has decided she likes Chinese food after all, having announced she absolutely hated Chinese food and wouldn’t go to a Chinese restaurant under any circumstances (L: M says I’m contrary. I know what it means, it means you make your mind up and then you change it. The spring rolls were absolutely delicious at the Blue Dragon. The fish - it wasn’t for eating – was very fat.)
There’s always the threat of a return to McDs to bring the troops in line. One evening, in despair of finding anything else, we enforced a sociological ‘field-trip’ to McDs for chicken McMaharajah and McAlooTikki. We were surprised to see that it was there at all, since the Rough Guide mentions that it had mysteriously and satisfyingly burnt down soon after opening, in this famously communist city. The chicken nuggets were okay (for W), the chips extremely salty, but the Indo-fast food hybrids too awful to dwell on, so let’s not. We’re looking forward to SE Asian food with a vengeance, even if we know that the children will start complaining and wishing for Indian food when faced with more new stuff...
The WPs are in disgrace with the children as we have enforced a slum clearance in their bedroom. Lucky they have no legal rights in this matter. They had constructed a tent city out of blankets and sheets and were planning to sleep in them (great idea - under fleecy blankets, beyond the reach of the fan...) which was offending my sense of ‘domestic’ (pah!) order. Better to accept our collective nomadic squalor? And for the record, they were not playing at being street kids, but armies...
L: So, Mum? MUM! MUUUUUM!
On our way home tonight, we stopped at the Calcutta Museum to find out if it’s open tomorrow (it’s Holi tomorrow which is a holiday). Unfortunately, we were invited in to see what was happening. There was a Spring Festival of Colour and there were women dancing and there was a woman dressed up as Krishna (he’s the God of Love – ohee!). I had to tell Mum and Dad it was a woman, but M told me first....The dancing was very, very silly I thought. I didn’t like the music either. They treated us like special guests: they made us sit at the front, W had a special garland (so we fought about that) but they put purple powder on all our foreheads (it’s a sign of Spring, for Holi, but I’m not so sure). Hmm. On Holi, people tip paint or squirt paint from water guns on you which I’m quite excited about. If anyone says, “Do you want paint on your head?” I’ll say “YES PLEASE!” I’m going to wear my stinkiest, oldest, girliest clothes that I don’t like. [WPs: It is highly unlikely that anyone will seek her formal consent.]
Anything exciting going on in Beckley? Maybe we can do Holi in Beckley when I come back? Do any of you think that’d be any fun? Shall we do paint water-guns?
Some of you may know that we were expecting to see Miss Cow in Cow-Cutta, but I forgot about her phone call last week, and she’s gone to Brazil urgently. (WM: Point of fact - cows aren’t allowed in the middle of Kolkata). Back on the start of my trip to India, I writ in WD’s diary and it said that he would go to dinner with Miss Cow and after a while Miss Cow wanted to marry him. But now Miss Cow’s really angry with him because he didn’t come to dinner with her. (WM: Is there no end to L’s extraordinary fantasy life?)
I’m scratching my head and thinking of more gossip. Do you have any? I think you do! Well I need to go and brush my teeth, so goodnight. Mum come and read us ‘The Hobbit’.
WD: Kolkata (and yes, it’s still Calcutta too) retains much of the colonial city, the imperial capital, that it once was, however decaying visibly. The colonial past is so much more visible here than in Delhi where the massive New Delhi project that created a vast empty, green centre with wide avenues to the city in the 1930s was so fleeting and indeed so unlike anything in Britain that it doesn’t feel particularly British at all. But in Calcutta there is a much longer, sustained legacy of the European presence – the architecture that we mentioned above, from the late eighteenth century on, the street and building names, the men are still wearing cricket whites on the huge dusty Maidan (unlike all the World Cup international players on everyone’s television screen at present).
Down the road from us is Park Street cemetery, a quiet walled haven from the city outside, with rows of late eighteenth and early nineteenth-century monuments to the heroic imperial dead (‘respected in life, lamented in death’ etc.) – soldiers, children, young women – a reminder of what a pestilential city it used to be (past tense obviously). It’s rather magnificent with crows and horrid dogs wandering amongst the Gothic tombs. The finest tomb is ‘Hindoo’ Stuart’s with temple columns and cusped arches: he went native, scandalising early nineteenth-century society by dressing like a Brahmin and amassing a fine collection of sculpture (that’s now in the BM). Sunnier – and earlier – than London’s Kensal Rise and Highgate cemeteries, but the same cult of death. Good film-set.
WM: Phew, Bilbo’s escaped from those horrid goblins...I don’t remember enjoying the Hobbit all that much when my Dad read it to me, never having been much of a dragons-and-dungeons girl, but the WolfGang are transfixed. Maybe it’s the themes of travel, adversity and adventure?
I’m a direct descendant of a colonial Scot who lived and worked as a jeweller in Calcutta around the turn of the twentieth century, and there’s tragedy in this tale too – a maternal great-grandmother bravely travelled from Scotland to India, had two sons (the younger my grandfather), before becoming ill and dying young, never reaching home. And whilst I’m deeply sceptical of the faux sentimentality and personal journey-theme of ‘Who do you think you are?’, it’s interesting to think just how directly the great project of Empire has affected my family, as so many others. It feels pre-history though, this colonial period: the crumbling, blackened buildings (one seen with a Banyan tree root system woven into its fabric), still inhabited though ruined, alongside the changing fortunes and growing confidence of Modern India, inversely mirrored by the decline of Britain.
We visited the Victoria Memorial, a white marble ‘Taj’ for the dead Empress, with lovely green gardens and home to great Colonial treasures (including the Daniells’ c.1800 paintings of lots of the places we’ve seen – the best a stormy picture of Rameshvaram, which entirely echoed our own experience), good weapons (for W) juxtaposed next to a photo exhibition of the Saintly Mother Teresa and a very even-handed ‘Calcutta Gallery’ about the history of the place and its encounters with Britain and the West. We especially liked hearing about the life of the Britishers here in the 18th Century - “they lead a leisurely life and entertain themselves in a variety of ways. Numerous dinner parties are held, with elaborate menus, at which flicking of bread pills is apparently, a common form of amusement” - so very like the lives of the Wolfgang, then.
WD: I’ve been out walking a lot, through the busy streets past the pavement sellers of t-shirts and underwear, religious and pornographic DVDs, padlocks, recycled bags; around the Victorian covered market, quickly through the overpoweringly smelly aisles where chickens are slaughtered; past the men typing letters on ancient typewriters (remember them?); the men drinking tea from small unfired clay cups and eating puri-bhaji from a moulded leaf plate. I’ve always walked around cities, not just because I’m too stingy to use taxis, but because I like seeing a place from the ground and getting to know your way around with a rough map in hand. This does of course mean I get a bit carried away and walk ridiculous distances in the heat, long past the moment when a route is actually interesting. Foolish when it’s just me, but not so kind when the others are coming too.
We all went on just such a mad escapade yesterday looking for another branch of FabIndia to stock up on more block-printed cotton, pukka wear for the memsahib and mini-memsahibs gone native in the heat. The pavements were a disaster-zone of fragmented and expelled paving slabs, and exposed cables and wiring, and other hazards. The desired address seemed to be perpetually a little further when we repeatedly asked... This was definitely urban adventure walking at its ‘finest’, an extreme sport demanding constant vigilance, stamina, sweat and with points deducted for losing a child in the crowds or getting run-over at the junctions and survival as the end and only goal. We enjoyed a splendid view of the underside of one of Calcutta’s new flyovers as we stumbled along past the intense humanity of the roadsides and the blaring traffic. The children were impressively stoic (maybe it was just impossible to hear their complaints over the noise of the traffic?) and we were once again reminded how wonderful and what doughty travellers they have become. It’s hard to imagine transporting them anywhere more difficult and different to their home environment [Downtown Lagos next summer? Or I’ve heard Libya’s attracting foreign visitors this year]. Eventually, we reached the AC of our destination, spent a lot and took a taxi home.
Lesson learnt? No, I’m a city-walker and if distances are long – as they are to head south to the Kalighat temple – then there’s a bus or the Metro. Figuring out the right route and finding your way is part of learning about the place. For an excellent account of contemporary Delhi by another city-walker, inspired by the romantic French flaneurs I believe, we recommend you all read Sam Miller’s Delhi: adventures in a megacity, a terrific view of the eccentricities, irritations and wonder of modern India.
WM: Well, I think WD and the rest of us will be forced to take it easy tomorrow, as it sounds as if everything closes down for Holi. Hard to imagine a city like this closing-down, but still... We’ve seen the queues for whiskey at the English Wine shops and have failed to buy our own, let alone paint and water guns. Underprepared?



